Damn, what a thread. Mommy in a response to Dana up the thread a way, you state that some perspective of hers must be "in her head." I don't know if you're aware of it, but virtually ALL child abusers when confronted state that the abuse they're being confronted with is just the abusee's "imagination." This is invalidating, marginalizing, and exculpatory. When anyone uses that kind of approach later in life, it pushes buttons all over the place. It really does take a lot of sensistivity to speak to an adult survivor and not step on toes.
I'm 56 years old and was raised in an utterly dysfunctional home. My father was a drunken, loud, threatening, semi-illiterate ass hole. He ruled by intimidation. No one knew what microscopic infraction was going to set him off - or even if an infraction was needed. Sometime he exploded for no reason at all. He would even get furious at inantimate objects like, say, a hammer. And would throw it across a room. I saw him get angry at a wrench once and he picked up a ten pound sledge hammer and beat the wrench with it. No kidding.
I've got most of my "father" buttons disconnected. However a few remain. And it's not a good idea to even get close to, much less press, one of my father buttons. The sensitivity that remains, all these years later, is truly amazing. And the intensity of my reactions surprises even me. Just be careful is all I'm saying. The way you address Dana really is over the top.
Francois