The fact that these Mexican immigrants are a PLUS to our economy is a fact. They do the jobs that nobody else wants to do. As for working under the table, MOST of the people I know of all races prefer to work under the table - because the taxes on personal income are ridiculous. The solution to getting them on the tax rolls is not excluding them - because that is impossible. They are here, and they are here to stay, and no amount of laws or efforts to deport them can prevent it. What we can do is MAKE THEM LEGAL and therefore a greater percentage of them will be registered to paying the various tax burdens, both STATE and FEDERAL. Yes, illegal immigrants ARE a drain on the economy, because they don't pay taxes. Technically, even a natural-born American is a "drain" if he's not paying all his taxes. Therefore, declare amnesty, get them registered, get them paying taxes!
The US needs MORE workers, working minimum wage jobs, and paying taxes, just to keep up with SS expenditures. Who cares if they spend it in Mexico or the US? The dollar will become even more universal than it already is. The Social Security system was designed with the idea that there would always be MORE workers than retirees. Thanks to medical advances and greying populations, mentioned elsewhere, we need immigrant workers.
No, I don't live in the border states. I do, however, work a low wage job, have worked all my life in restaurants with minorities and immigrants, some of which were illegal. I'm sorry if working at Pizza Hut is beneath you - but take comfort that your high-tech jobs did not disappear because of NAFTA. These MEXICAN immigrants - a country that I think we can afford a special immigration relationship with - will be working low wage jobs as dishwashers precisely because they can room with two or three friends and be able to send a couple of hundred dollars home - where it is worth a lot more.
I'm not interested in the hypothetical futures presented here, where American culture is subsumed by some kind of "brown tide" from the south. Such Malthusian prophecies inevitably fall short of expectation, and reveal the real reason that some are afraid to open the border. I wonder how much of the "concern" about these immigrants economic standing is based on old-fashioned xenophobia? I would have thought that we would have had enough of such apocalyptic hyperbole in the Borg.
The lengthy article claimed that NAFTA wrecked both the Mexican and United States economies. I hope it is easy to see that these claims are contradictory.
Things change, people. You cannot hold back the world. China, the most xenophobic country in the world, is starting to crack, bit by bit. Yes, our culture will change, probable drastically as a result of an initiative to open the border. But that's life. It would have happened gradually already if we hadn't tried to close the border.
A Mexican citizen can come here and get a job. That's my goal.
CZAR