Although I don't agree with kneehghmiah's thread name, this has proved to be an excellent thread. As Ignoranceisbliss has put it,
"This is a really interesting discussion. A lot of great points were made."
As to the supposed WTS's demise, LostGeneration has it right:
"Nobody here wants to read this, I'd say they have adapted nicely in the last few years. Massive reductions in expenses, huge cash inflows from property and now the new building fund. Just notice on another thread a congo send off more than $25k and pledged another $1100 a month until Armageddon, and we all know how long that will be. Not all US/UK congos will go that high, but this plan is a golden goose.
They needed to institute some sort of tithe, but just not call it a tithe. Send out yearly reminders and the resolutions will creep up in $ amounts."
BTW, LostGeneration, I want to read such comments! Not that I agree with their money-mongering, of course.
And steve2's words are also apt:
"Well-publicized unfavorable developments in religious groups do not lead to exodus. If fact, there's a kind of "group huddle" in which a publicly criticized group closes ranks and has its own "take" on the publicity that often leads to the rank and file becoming more committed to their affiliation. It's the 'being-tested-by-fire' phenomenon. So, if people here are hanging out for a major breaking story within the organization, better take stock and realize that, even in the event of a major disturbing development, it will most likely not have any hoped-for longer-term detrimental impact and - if anything - feed the hungry persecution complex that awakens easily within the organization."
So the Org will last a long time, many posters' wishful thoughts on this forum notwithstanding. James Brown's words strike a real chord:
"The Watchtower today, is not the Watchtower [I knew].
They did not have a governing body; they had a president.
They believed millions who saw 1914 and were of a discernable age in 1914 would not pass away.
The Sunday talks used to be an hour.
Pioneering was 100 hours a month.
The United nations was bad, not something that they would belong to.
They had a piano player play the piano before, during and after the meetings.
They had a band/orchestra at the assemblies.
They cooked good cafeteria food at the assemblies.
The congregations had picnics often and played sports together every week."
I suppose the GB feels that Satan has been attacking the Org most recently thru the courts. They've reacted by all this closing ranks, worshipping unity, and money hoarding. What they apparently do not realize is that even if they are right, then the devil has succeeded in taking much of the joy out of being in the Org by THEIR reactions. Hence James Brown's final 4 observations.
Thx to many for their thoughts.