Good point Scully. It was this premise that bought us into the org over 20 years ago.
Off course back then there wasnt the information so easily available to be able to double check what the JW's were telling us.
I did plough through a couple of their more obscure books "Legally establishing and defending the good news" and the first book on their history, cant remember the name but is was written as a question and answer dialogue (An A4 dark green book I seem to remember), but off course there wasnt anything in them to ring warning bells.
Fortunately that same attitude stayed with us and although we remained for about 18 years-other half was an elder-we still remained open minded (thank goodness).
We as a family used to openly discuss the unchristian attitudes we saw displayed. This was in the later years once the children became teenagers.
We also used to discuss the contents of the meeting on the way home in the car and more times than not the fact that a specific point had gone counter to an item given recently. ie Make quality time for your children, Do more in the field service, Is your home and garden as neat and well run as the Bethel-It should be, and many less thoughtful elders would use such items to bully the cong especially sisters in divided homes.
We made sure our children saw these things as they happened but my husband never betrayed a confidence as regards any elders meetings etc.
Over the last 4 years we have gradually withdrawn totally from the org and no one has come to see us to ask why
During this time we have researched the society on the internet and bought both of Ray Franz's books.
I suppose for us the thing was always being honest with each other and loving each other with complete trust.
We came in as a family.
We left as a family.