What is the Purpose of this Site - My personal opinion?

by jst2laws 112 Replies latest jw friends

  • Sassy
    Sassy

    When I decided to stop being a JW, SimpleSally told me how supportive the people have been on this site and recommended I join up. I was a little hesitant at first not sure how welcomed I would be so was a bit more quiet at first (not my usual nature). But she was right about the people here. And this site is theraputic for those having left the JW life. True we could go to a therapist but unless they are an ex JW, there are some things you just can't relate and feel like you are understood. And sometimes we know the answers any way, but to have a friend who can say, I know, I was there. You can see how far they have come and feel strength to see you can get there too or you can get there together.

    While it is true, there is an amount of rebellion one can feel after leaving the JWs and since it can be new terrritory, we might not be sure how to behave. But the fact of the matter is, just because we aren't JWs any more, doesn't mean we have to become people who have no conscience or care for other peoples feelings. Then does that make us better people for having left the religion? Actually it gives them reason to think they are right to stay a JW, because look how angry this person or that became. We're all angry. I'm angry that I lost so much all those years, but that doesn't make it right for me to not care about how I behave in front of others.

    This site is like visiting someone's home, Simon and Angharad's home. How would we feel if people came into our home and argued to the point of offending other guests we have invited. Not very good if we are decent human beings. It is no different here. The hours they put in to maintain this home, to arrange for others to be on "household duty" of keeping things orderly, we need to respect and appreciate.

  • ScoobySnax
    ScoobySnax

    Chris, I hope you realise I'm using my last post on you here, following my reduction !!!

    I think you're a Good Man. Thats what I meant. I'd like to be someone who gets his head sorted without having to keep looking over his shoulder all the time wondering if I did/said the right thing. I'd like to be a man that see's beyond the black and white of a situation. I'd like to be like the phrase goes, someone who my dog thinks I am. etc.

    Life is a magazine, make yours the colour supplement.

    Scoob

  • minimus
    minimus

    My take on this site is actually pretty simple. It's to help people get OUT of the Watchtower ---Not IN! As I've said before, if you were at an AA meeting and you constantly wanted to talk about why alcohol is so good, I think you'd be talked to. If you continued espousing the virtues of alcohol, I'd bet you wouldn't feel very welcomed. When posters, month after month, attempt to sponsor pro-WT. agendas on this site, I think it's rather insulting to the vast majority of posters.

  • fearnotruth22
    fearnotruth22

    To say that JWS do not have the truth is a conclusion.When one says help anothe understand one actually means to force another to "understand" OUR conclusion and that is not freedom of the mind but "a white man's burden" ( dont conclude that I am black, I am not). All one should do is exhibit facts and arguments and allow individuals to think for themselves and be supportvie as to their concerns but allow them to decide for themselves and come to their personal conclusions. When one says one wants to help someone understand is with the premise that one is right and they are wrong and we want to converst them to understand things our way. Is not that what the WT does?

    What the WT hhas besides billions are teachings and doctrines and interpretations as to what the Bible means and the international brotherhood and they also claim to be the exclusive agency of God.

    Is this all true? At least the billions of dollars is true I hear. As to all the other stuff, who really knows?

    Keeping with the Theme of this Board, let's not discuss things that are pro wt, but what can be shown is the controversial side that challenge wt claims to help individuals make personal choices and let the viewer believe what he wants and not what he is coerced to belive. This is my view.

  • ScoobySnax
    ScoobySnax

    who are these posters Mini that have such a damaging effect on this forum who maybe pro-JW? Theres me SoJ and erm........isn't that it? This isn't alcoholics anon. This a JWDiscussion forum....everyone Welcome. You have 99% backing here, what riles you so much about the 1%? What is being run here? A discussion forum or a bootcamp? Conversly I think personally by your views you insult a great many posters here. Unlike you they can accept the odd dissenter and still sleep well. You don't seem to be able to. You appear to have gone from one tunneled vision to another in a very small jump.

  • Big Tex
    Big Tex

    Well said Scooby.

    And no offense here. I knew what you meant.

    Now, give yourself that gift. You know who you want to be -- now go out and do it. Become that man. Forgive the hokiness, but as Buddhist proverb says, "A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step."

  • nowisee
    nowisee

    ok, so let me backtrack......

    what this site did for me:

    l) made me aware i was not alone

    2) made me feel there were other people i could talk to....about subjects that were not totally alien....

    3) totally confirmed that wts was false prophet

    4) made me realize that many xjws are reliable good people.....

    could any of the above be related to the purpose of this site??

  • Stacy Smith
    Stacy Smith
    That's what I think the board is about. What do you think. Steve

    Ummm Steve I think that is what this board is supposed to be about and what it should be about. Perhaps if the owner of this board himself stopped contributing to political threads and even put a stop to such threads it would stay better focused. I see a purpose to discuss daily subjects but obviously political threads don't work well here.

    If we talked about religion and our personal lives without bringing up how much Bush/Dean sucks there wouldn't be so much complaining about moderation or the unlevel playing field. I'll bet it would even be a much more pleasant place to visit. The name calling might even go away.

  • smack
    smack

    I'm unsure of the purpose anymore. I haven't been here long, and I'd forgotten most of the JW way. What I have learned over the last few months from all posters is amazing. I'm having a visit from my brother in a few weeks time, he's visiting my town to attend the assembly that is doing the rounds. I'm here gathering information to counter the "encouraging" that I'm sure I will recieve. He's blindly followed the way for nearly 50 years, never doubted, never had a problem......until this year. I have to have facts and proof to show him in answer to any comments he makes to me. Having knowledge of what food he's about to recieve at the assembly is going to be an enormous head start for me. But I digress.

    This help and info has come from all posters, and I'm probably going to get in trouble, but the ones that showed me the most are the ones that have been kicked out. Can't you see that to leave the borg, you have to be different, you have to be a bit firey, you have to stand up and question...and KEEP questioning. This board has all the answers I need, but the source of a lot of that info has been discarded.

    People, why can't you work out your differences instead of deleting, censoring and fighting. I'm not going to say it's like the bad old days of borgdumb because it's not. But you can't discard posters because they don't tow the party line.

    There are 3 things that should never be discussed.

    Sex

    Politics

    Religion.

    What can we discuss then? Wake up and become a bit more tolerant before you lose your complete knowledge base!

    *rant mode off*

    Steve

  • Stacy Smith
    Stacy Smith
    There are 3 things that should never be discussed.

    Sex

    Politics

    Religion.

    Well Religion is something that's always going to be discussed here. Sex can be discussed if done in a manner that is suitable for let's say, younger people. Politics? Poison here. Very bad and the source of the majority of problems on this website. It's apparent that politics brings out the worst in all of us.

    speaking of sex......seeya later

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit