Why do people pretend good things about Jesus ?

by mP 418 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • tec
    tec

    So how do you explain someone who can say all those same things, but has arrived there without hearing any voices?

    Same as those who have the law (of love) written naturally on their hearts. They do by nature what some need to be taught.

    Are those not the goals that pretty much all humans have?

    I don't think so.

    If we can reach those goals without requiring a "voice" to tell us how to behave, then what is the benefit of hearing the voices or beliving in Christ?

    Well, some need Him, for one.

    I don't think anyone scoffs at one more person loving them, or guiding, teaching, helping them. Especially not someone they also love. Sometimes that voice is a comfort and a helper. Who could not use one of those...in one form or another? Maybe there are some who do not want one of those... but I am not one of those few.

    Or do you believe that no one TRULY reaches those goals without Christ, so therefore you have achieved a superior goal than anyone else?

    Hopefully, what i have said above answers this question for you about what I think.

    Or are they LYING about having achieved those goals in their life?

    Same as above.

    If anyone who tries to be a better person can achieve those goals WITHOUT Jesus, then why do we need him?

    You speak we as if we are all the same... same needs/strengths/weaknesses. We are not.

    We do need Christ though, to approach His Father, if that is something you want to do. Now whether it is you who knows Him (though he must also know you), or Him who knows you (because of what is within you; even though you do not think you know him)... doesn't matter. We enter His Kingdom (and life) through Him.

    Personally, I love Him. So I want Him in my life.

    Peace,

    tammy

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    You speak we as if we are all the same... same needs/strengths/weaknesses. We are not.

    Exactly, you can't put the human brain into a box, you just can't. There is a leaning in us all to just generalize to solve internal dissonance, but the reality is that we need Christ because humanity needs Christ and always has. What happens when a human loses all hope? Where can they turn? No where? That's not true, they can turn to Christ as they can if they are successful too. If someone has success in life and doesn't have Christ, that's great. But it's not the right of that person who succeeded to demand that everyone else succeed as well because they did without Christ. Circumstances are so different that it would be arrogent to think such a thing. So instead of just letting be, they say Christ is not divine.

    -Sab

  • King Solomon
    King Solomon

    Well, we're beating a dead horse.

    Tammy concisely answered "why people choose to believe in an idealized Disneyesque version of Jesus, despite the actual behaviors and beliefs indicated in the Bible:

    Personally, I love Him. So I want Him in my life.

    Here's some music for you, Tammy:

    For you, Tammy:

  • sabastious
    sabastious

    For you KS:

    1 Cor 4 - 10 We are fools for Christ, but you are so wise in Christ! We are weak, but you are strong! You are honored, we are dishonored!

    -Sab

  • palmtree67
    palmtree67
    What happens when a human loses all hope? Where can they turn? No where? That's not true, they can turn to Christ

    So how do you explain that I've saved MYSELF from every situation where I needed to be saved? I prayed and prayed during molestation, rape, abuse, stalking, harrassment.....etc. Nothing happened until I made up my mind to save MYSELF.

    PALM:Are those not the goals that pretty much all humans have?

    TEC: I don't think so.

    I guess I have more faith in my fellow humans than you do.

  • tec
    tec

    If you haven't read a headline lately, there's no way of getting to know him now: he's been dead for 2,000 yrs.

    I guess He didn't get that headline either. Because he is alive, in Spirit. Risen.

    You don't believe that, I know. But that doesn't make it any less true.

    Aside from the inconvenience of his being dead and all, you forget that once I DID believe in him; I felt his presence, his comfort, his love.

    How could you have felt those things if he does not exist?

    Or are you saying that he does?

    (I know, I know... you just thought you felt those things)

    And you know what? It felt pretty damned goooood, basking in the warm glow of his loving kindness, warmth, grace, compassion, wisdom, mercy: all of it. I imagined him when I was being persecuted (like when two bullies who tormented me that year because I didn't salute the flag tried to prod me into a fight on the playground; I silently prayed for strength, and they gave up after I repeatedly said I wouldn't fight, over and over).

    Good for you for standing your ground and not letting them bully you into being other than the person you wanted to be.

    I imagined him when I did something I thought would please him and God, and felt he was proud of me. My own father lived away (parents were divorced), so he was maybe like a step-father, the proxy male-authority figure who was always there. I was raised by a single mom, and there were four kids in the house.

    And perhaps he was.

    You disbelieving him now would not change what might have been true then.

    So I know what you feel, Tams: everyone here does, too! We ALL felt it...

    You know some. Not all. Otherwise i would have nothing to say that you did not once believe yourself. I would not have to explain anything. But this is not the case.

    Some here probably would continue feeling his warmth, but got DFed (which is a blessing in disguise: they were forced to go cold-turkey on their addiction to Jesus Juice™), others still sought the same high except from another Juice™ dealer (pushing another flavor of Juice™), and others felt disillusioned and rejected, condemned by the Jesus whom they loved, etc. Some don't experience anything except relief, some don't think about it, and others are angry, or riddled with guilt. Everybody has a different story.

    Agreed. So stop pretending that your story is the same as mine.

    Do you think that because this is what you have concluded that it must be the end product and if others conclude something different, then they are all wrong. Only you can be right?

    Some of us listened to 1 Cor 13:11: "When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put childish ways behind me." That's what happened to me: I grew up, and fortunately didn't have as strong family pressure to continue, so I grew up with a way to escape. I was a good reader, and read books that challenged the belief system (Orwell's 1984 comes to mind: required reading, if anyone hasn't read it).

    You think Paul was referring to faith when he said that?

    My intellectual curiosity led me to a world I never imagined existed in the JWs, and I literally would have to experience MAJOR HEAD TRAUMA to ever consider believing in what I 100% KNOW to be a seductive but massive lie, built up over 1,000's of years, one that is SO GRAND that it's not fully comprehended by many people. I'd have to forget everything I've learned about the natural World, and the accumulated knowledge handed down to us from prior generations (Galileo, DaVinci, Copernicus, Descartes, Watson and Crick, Einstein, etc, etc) that I could never unring THAT bell.

    You think i do not have a love or interest in science? Or the natural world?

    One can have this; one can study this and other religions and philosophers and still have Christ.

    Once you have gained knowledge of how things REALLY DO WORK (eg biochemistry, physiology, genetics, etc), there's no putting a mind back behind bars, asking it to believe ancient superstitions.

    Again, love all the sciences and the possibilities they show, as well as the workings they show for now. No bars. At all. I can accept and love science... and embrace and love Christ and God.

    Peace,

    tammy

  • King Solomon
    King Solomon

    Sab said:

    But it's not the right of that person who succeeded to demand that everyone else succeed as well because they did without Christ. Circumstances are so different that it would be arrogent to think such a thing. So instead of just letting be, they say Christ is not divine.

    Reality doesn't really care why you accept it, or even that you DO accept it, or ask your permission to be what it is: it just IS.

    You choose to accept a fantasy, but hopefully a part of you understands that your rejection of reality IS only that: a self-induced delusion, a denial.

  • palmtree67
    palmtree67

    It's really a yes or no thing:

    Do we need Jesus' voice whispering in our ear to become better people? Yes or No?

    If the answer is YES, then you are saying that you are better than others. No other way of looking at it.

    If the answer is NO, then why do we need him whispering in our ear?

    Simple.

  • tec
    tec

    I guess I have more faith in my fellow humans than you do.

    Or you don't have the same experiences as i have.

    I know people who do not share those goals. I know many people who believe vengeance is better than forgiveness. Who STATE so, clearly. I know people who think that the herd (humans) should be culled, so that there should be no money wasted on bringing comfort to the elderly or the terminally ill. They should just...die. And i know people who WANT to hold onto anger. Do they ever change and grow? Some do... and I hope the others will. But that does not change that at any given time, there are many people who do not share those goals.

    Peace,

    tammy

  • tec
    tec

    It's really a yes or no thing:

    No. It is not. Because we are not all the same.

    Do we need Jesus' voice whispering in our ear to become better people? Yes or No?

    Some of us do.

    (it is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick)

    If the answer is YES, then you are saying that you are better than others. No other way of looking at it.

    But the answer was not yes.

    If the answer is NO, then why do we need him whispering in our ear?

    The answer was also not, no.

    Peace,

    tammy

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit